Sonadow
SonicXShadow
Reviews For Going Back

Name: littledragon12344 (Signed) · Date: July 17, 2014 1:10 AM · For: Message in the Trees
more pls it very good :)


Name: Blue Speedster (Signed) · Date: August 28, 2010 3:21 PM · For: Remembering

Well I think that story was really cool, I dnt know why people are so mean about it, randomers, don't pay any attention, anyway, it would be great if you wrote more I was really getting into it, and its interesting and different, confusing about mirror tho, I understand the story and stuff, but not how he developed mirror in the first place lol



Name: Hell_is _on_fire (Signed) · Date: June 11, 2008 1:05 AM · For: Message in the Trees
Hey

i haven't gotten into it becuase there is not enough for me to get into. so write a little more and i'll be loving it

maybe you could put a lttle explanation about mirror in there somewhere. something like that would be great. maybe alos more about sonic's past life

bye for now not forever


Name: deathblast (Signed) · Date: March 24, 2008 6:37 PM · For: Message in the Trees
whoa guys stop with the negative comments, sigh don't listen to them i can read it fine plus the whole mirror things good it's like super in takashi's 'my black shadow' i can't wait for the next part

Author's Response: There not that bad, i've gotten used to them. I also read 'my black shadow' so yeah Mirror is kind of like that. Not as insane but kind of close.


Name: Mechaknucles (Signed) · Date: March 23, 2008 11:23 PM · For: Message in the Trees
Chapter 1
Unclear, very superficial, overall, interesting, but too general. I have a vague idea of what is going on, but so far, I haven't really understood ANYTHING you are trying to relate to me. I am not even sure how this is supposed to be read with the misspellings, odd cut offs, and overall lack of detail or description. I feel like I am reading notes that you had to have read the story to understand rather than reading an actual story. Really bad 3/10.
Chapter 2
Okay, wtfs a mirror? Also, you don't explain anything I read this twice, as though a second read might make everything pop into place. Sorry but, it didn't. It actually made me realize that you just don't care about the kind of crap you unleash onto the site. As for Takashi, he(again, she? You really need to tell someone so we know...) is really the least likely person to "flame" you. I am a thousand times harsher simply because I don't like garbage. (Even if I have some, I will at least have the decency to put a label on it going, "This is garbage.") Now, on topic with the story.
YOU CANNOT INTERRUPT DIALOG WITH VAGUE REFERENCES TO CHARACTER UNLESS IT IS RELATED OR HAPPENING AT THE SAME TIME. AND, IF YOU DO THIS CORRECTLY, YOU SHOULD GIVE A GOOD ENOUGH DESCRIPTION SO THAT I KNOW WTF YOU'RE DOING! Is it too hard to ask for you to explain wth your characters are!?!? Could you describe him, or do we magically assume it is a talking mirror? And what in God's name is a dark? To stop myself from continuing this rant-as doing so would cause my head to explode in sheer frustration-, could you stay in one tense!!!!!!

Author's Response: I'm oddly not shocked by your review. this is merely a little test run i'm doing, so it won't be the best. I didn't want people coming here saying "It's so horrible!" Or something along though lines. But you didn't do that so your not really flaming me at the moment.


Name: Nightshade (Signed) · Date: March 23, 2008 11:01 PM · For: Message in the Trees
interesting....I like the idea of Sonic having a separate personality inside him that takes control you still coulda gotten longer and try adding a bit more detail

Author's Response: Thank you, i'll try to be longer and try to add more detail.


Name: Takashi the hedgehog (Signed) · Date: March 23, 2008 9:22 PM · For: Message in the Trees
People don't flame on this site, most times. And if you ever felt I was a flamer, I apologize. I only try to help others. Any who, HTMLs? < i > for italics (without spaces) and in order to get rid of them, put down < / i > (without spaces). See? Same goes with bold words, only with a "b". Oh, and underlined words, I think. (But with a "u".) ^^

Now, about your healthy dose of constructive criticism.... More explanations, please. I have no idea what a "Dark" is, nor do I know what a chao has to do with the plot (or Mirror, for that matter). Remember that what you write is for the audience. I dunno if I missed a subtext, but it's all very confusing. Perhaps you will explain eventually and were planning for puzzlement. If so, ignore what I have said. My only other suggestion is your paragraphing/formatting could use some cleaning up. Save for that, nice job. ^^ Your length has improved immensely. Spelling's better, too. Keep up the good work.


Name: Takashi the hedgehog (Signed) · Date: March 22, 2008 8:27 PM · For: Remembering
As long as your fancharacters are not Mary-Sues, I'm fine with them. Any who, beginning+corny sentence about evil=bad. Ending of chapter is also corny, thus bad. It's also too short. At least, 500 words, my fellow author. And, you spelled a few words wrong. Shinny--shiny, etc. I except you should have been able to edit this in ease since it's only 296 words. Everyone's different, though.

On the other paw, I love the bad guy so far. He sounds very original. Psycho obsessive villain+sweet plot=fantastic. I like those two highly important aspects and I can't wait to see what happens next. Just watch your length, grammar, and spelling. Oh, and beware the corny sentences. 'Kay? Hope I helped. ^^


Name: deathblast (Signed) · Date: March 22, 2008 5:27 PM · For: Remembering
i see nothing wrong with this a bit short but not bad, also it say's that the story is finished you might wanna change that


Name: Nightshade (Signed) · Date: March 22, 2008 5:17 PM · For: Remembering
interesting beginning.....I hope to see what happened in Sonic's past that made him act this way....only spelling error I caught was sceaked....I think you mean squeaked


You must login (register) to review.

Sonic and Shadow (c) and TM SEGA - Sonic Team

Sonadow Online
http://www.sonadow.com
2003-2009