Sonadow
SonicXShadow
Reviews For Comatose

Name: Ruo-chamasama (Signed) · Date: June 22, 2009 10:03 PM · For: Comatose
My Number 1 favorite story. I love the feeling and emotion this story shows. It made me cry. Then I listened to the song and I loved it. You are extremely talented.


Name: JPMJSonadowlover (Signed) · Date: December 22, 2008 12:59 PM · For: Comatose
It made me cry. It was good but oh so sad.


Name: Kailartemis (Signed) · Date: October 11, 2008 1:02 PM · For: Comatose
This is a song by Skillet! I like this song and great story. I usued to think in this manner when I was younger...actually I somewhat fell inot the state Sonic was in at the end. Trust me, being out for almost 2 weeks is not cool.

There were errors I spotted in this, but as everyone else is making me do I can't tell you what they are (supposed to help me become a better writter). Anyways, hope you write something else soon.

Author's Response: Oo no way...wow. Mmmm, yeah i'm not perfect errors are in my genetic make-up thing. mmmm....thankd or reading and taking the time to comment.


Name: Dark_Eyes (Signed) · Date: May 24, 2008 8:19 AM · For: Comatose
This reminds me of a movie I watched when I was a child. Her husband dies and she wakes up in random places and diffenrent periods of time. I can't actually remember what it was called, but I know that she goes to the place of her husband's death and I can't remember wether she dies or goes back to normal. Her daughter runs through the glass doors, which made me laugh! Anyway, really good! I like it! It's cute! heres a hug for you:-


Author's Response: XDDD thanks


Name: Taranea (Signed) · Date: April 29, 2008 6:03 PM · For: Comatose
Oh, wow...*pokes fingers together* that was actually heart-breaking. As you may have seen from my own sonadow fic I can only deal with comedy stuff. (drop)^^

I really liked the way the lyrics fit in there, especially the last lines. I was kinda thinking during the middle of this that Sonic was hallucinating, but that he hadn't been awake for years...*shudder* In a very gothic way it's beautiful, though. Thanks for writing this!

Author's Response: lol, even so, I'm glad you read my lil (not really little) fic. really? glad you caught on to it, that just means I was dropping enough hints here and there :) and thanks for the review


Name: spandexsyn (Signed) · Date: April 27, 2008 7:57 PM · For: Comatose
very good story, strong in the emotion department. hope you write another one soon.

Author's Response: thanks for the review, glad you liked it. as for another one, this was intended as a one-shot, so yeah :)


Name: Nightshade (Signed) · Date: April 27, 2008 8:51 AM · For: Comatose
aww....that's kinda sad....but it was really good too.

Author's Response: glad it got a reaction outta yoi, that means I was doing something right :) ad you liked it. Thanks for the review!!


Name: Mechaknucles (Signed) · Date: April 27, 2008 12:32 AM · For: Comatose
Negative points:
“Sonic sighed as he looked out the window, the warm pleasing sunlight dance along his shinning cobalt fur.”
-3 pts. Change of tense.

“ . . . def ears . . .”
-5pts. Spelling (deaf)

“‘How’d I get in bed?’ he asked, because all he remembered was falling asleep on the couch.”
-0 pt. Too Assuming, thus logically incorrect. Better is “How’d I get in bed?” he asked. He must not have remembered anything after he fell asleep on the couch.” No points are lost if you mean to suggest Sonic knew Shadow did not recall anything prior to falling asleep. (If not, -2 pts.)

-2 points grammar. “‘"I love you to Sonic.’”
I love you too, Sonic.

-3 pt. Grammar: “As the weenies boiled he went to the cupboard and got a small can of chili to finish off his chili dogs.”
As the weenies boiled, he went to the cupboard and got a small can of chili to finish off his chili dogs.
As a side note, I highly advise using grabbed or grasped because “got” really interrupts the flow of the sentence and story.

-3 pts. “It was a story about to sisters and how they each had a lover. ”
Two, not “to”

Positives (Bonus points):
Stream of Consciousness story +3
Ending flow from consciousness +1 (Could have been better)
Reason of insanity +1 (Also could have been better)
Random cookie points (Doesn't affect grade):
I actually like this story. It does an excellent job in actually PULLING me through the story. It made me want to keep reading, and I must say that you could have made one or two things better. My main thing is that, I feel it would have been very elegant to have Shadow actually end up living, showing up at the Hospital and never leaving Sonic's side. If you kept the ending under those circumstances, you would juxtapose the enormous difference in their will power. You could even dedicate a second chapter entirely to Shadow given the above idea, explaining how he deals with this, and tie in Shadow's actions to the comatose Sonic with the hallucinations. You might even explore the idea of Shadow's demons. But, even without this thought, the story serves an excellent example of story telling mastery and an overall extraordinary ability to use the rare-in-modern-form stream of consciousness technique. A thousand cookies to you!
Grade: 89%
Last words:
A must read tragedy.


Author's Response: wow.....y'know for a second there I wasn't gonna read this whole thing, but I wanted to know what you thought so. thanks for all the minus points, lol, I'm not good with the English language therefore I'm not so good with grammer. (really though :) ) I liked the word swapping suggestions, thanks. As far as the flow....I wrote this all off the top of my head, so flow was the last thing on my mind. I didn't want Shadow to show up at all because I didn't want it to be like that, sure it would have been a nice twist, but I figured if someone else wrote this they would have done that. I just wanted to make something different and a little realistic...I hope I did that pretty well. as for a sequel, I think, in the midst of my sickness I intended to keep this a one-shot, so I'll stick to that...for now I guess. Because I think a sequel would just drag? maybe...? um.....thanks for all the cookies XDD *shoves the cookies in a room* Oh, and thank you for the review (no one really reviews like this so THANK YOU), it opened my eyes a lot...I'm gonna have to go back and change somethings that you mentioned. um...what else....glad you liked it...IDK if I said that already and yeah....ja ne :)


Name: SonicSpartan (Signed) · Date: April 26, 2008 4:26 AM · For: Comatose
Must...not...cry. Damn, this and the ending to Cellar Door. That is a lot of emotion for one reading session.

I'm a sucker for a happy and/or crazy Sonic so this is rather heartbreaking but is also probably one of my favorite oneshots. It is rare for a oneshot to be this detailed and well-paced. They often feel too rushed or are drawn out to length worth of multiple chapters. Good job with this one and you have a talent for winding strange stories. Not everyone can make something like this work.

Author's Response: lol, I liked cellar door, kinda confusing, but all in all, pretty good. and thanks, glad you liked it :)


Name: Shadow456 (Signed) · Date: April 25, 2008 7:44 PM · For: Comatose
wow...this brought a tear to my eye...

Author's Response: .....does that mean you liked it? :/ In any case i'm glad it got a reaction out of you (as a reader), that means I was doing something right. Thanks much for the review


You must login (register) to review.

Sonic and Shadow (c) and TM SEGA - Sonic Team

Sonadow Online
http://www.sonadow.com
2003-2009